Cold email follow-ups that stop when people reply
Most replies come after a follow-up, not the first email. Follow-ups only work if they reach the inbox, say something new each time and stop the moment the person answers.
Send from your own mailbox, set up properly
- Send from a real mailbox on your own domain, so replies come straight back to you.
- Set up SPF, DKIM and DMARC for that domain. Without them, much of your mail lands in spam.
- Start with a small number of emails a day and grow slowly.
- Gmail and Yahoo expect bulk senders to offer one-click unsubscribe and to keep spam complaints low. It is good practice for everyone.
Write the first email
- Open with one real, recent reason to write: they just opened, raised money, hired or won a contract.
- One or two lines on what you do for businesses like theirs.
- One easy question to answer. No attachments and no long lists of features.
Write follow-ups that add something
- Two to four follow-ups, a few days apart, are usually enough.
- Each one adds something new: a short example, a useful idea, a simpler question. Avoid "just bumping this up".
- Send in the person's own working hours, in their time zone, and mind their public holidays.
- Stop everything as soon as they reply, unsubscribe or bounce.
Measure replies, not opens
Open tracking is no longer reliable: some mail apps load images for privacy, which counts as an open. Count replies, interested replies and meetings booked instead.
Do it in FarLeads
- In Mail, add your own mailbox under Mailboxes and press Check to test SPF, DKIM and DMARC.
- Create a campaign with the first email and follow-ups, using name chips for each lead's name and company.
- Choose Drafts only, I approve each email, or Fully automatic. Emails go out in each lead's working hours.
- Follow-ups stop when someone replies, every email carries one-click unsubscribe, and hot replies rise to the top.
